|
I see some of my movies say 4:3 and/or 16:9 Widescreen, what is the difference, and is one better then the other? |
-
To understand the answer to this question you may need to familiarize yourself
with the different aspect ratios of DVD’s. One of the better sites which discuss
this are at the digitialbits found here:
http://www.thedigitalbits.com/articles/anamorphic/anamorphic185demo.html
But once again, in simple terms, 4:3 refers to full screen or full frame. This
means that on a standard Television, the picture will fill up the screen
entirely. Some people are under the false impression that because the picture
fills up their screen, it must better. This is incorrect, and full screen
presentations of movies on DVD are actually not as good as 16:9. Again, this can
get complicated and in great detail, but simply put, when a movie is filmed it
is almost always filmed in a 1:85:1 or 2:35:1 aspect ratio. This ratio fits the
movie screens at the theaters wonderfully and when the movie makes its way to
DVD it can be digitally transferred leaving the original theatrical aspect ratio
untouched. This allows for the film to be viewed as the director wants it to be
viewed. Many studios in an effort to make more money will release both aspect
ratios of the film on completely separate discs which must be purchased
separately. These movies have been modified from their original format, so when
you watch them, they may fit your screen, but you aren’t watching them as the
director wanted you to see them. Some people will also agree with this but then
say that on a standard 4:3 Television, full screen is still better and on a
widescreen T.V 16:9 is better. This is usually because some people are annoyed
by the black bars when watching a 16:9 movie on a standard television. This is
also a false assumption, because once again, even with the black bars on a
standard T.V, you won’t see the characters as being stretched or morphed, and
you will still see the movie as it was meant to be seen. There are some very
good examples of how 4:3 modifications look very poor, but one of them is with
Charlies Angels 2: Full-Throttle. There is a scene in this movie on the full
screen version where the angels are sitting on the couch and they get a call
from Charlie. They are talking to Charlie, but you only see like 2 and ½ of the
angels, as the angel to the far right is cut off the screen. When you watch the
16:9, Widescreen version of this movie you see all 3 angels perfectly on the
couch because this is what the director wanted you to see. He wanted you to see
all 3 angels, not just 2 of them and the 3rd one partially cut off. When you
watch a 4:3 full-screen/full-frame presentation, you will usually know at the
beginning if it was originally in a different aspect ratio as it will state this
“this film has been modified to fit your screen” or something to that affect
|
|